Cart

Order a Cheesecake

Click on the date you would like to have your cheesecake available for In Person Pick Up or Local Delivery on Bainbridge Island.

Don’t see the date you’d like to order for? Please feel free to reach out to me at Kristin @thefantailfarm.com

To view all of our flavors with their descriptions visit the Gourmet Cheesecake page.

Photography by Dinah Satterwhite & Tony Johnson

Reviews by our customers…

We LOVE these cheesecakes! Truly amazing. They could not be fresher, come in so many delicious flavors, and get delivered right to our door! And Kristin is so sweet and nice too—it’s always such a treat to see her pull up. I don’t even usually like cheesecake these have made me a convert. The last eggnog one we bought became breakfast every morning for a week. Plus, we feel good knowing that we are supporting a local small business. We are so grateful for Fantail Farm! – JM

We ordered a cranberry cheesecake to share with family for Thanksgiving. The cheesecake was phenomenal! It was so creamy and had a great flavor profile with a delicious crust! We loved how natural it was and that it was just the right amount of sweet. We have tried cheesecakes from other places and they often are too sweet or thick, or the consistency is off. The Fantail Farm cheesecake was just wonderful! We are excited to order more and try some of the other flavors! Thank you Fantail Farm! 💜❄️ – RB

PSA I wanted to let people know about these delicious cheesecakes made here! (Woman-owned) I ordered one for a special luncheon – the peanut butter cup one – and it was delicious!! Everyone raved about it! I cut it into 16 pieces which was plenty big enough of a slice per person! Yum! -RDT

I wanted to let you all know that my dear friend Kristin has just started a custom cheesecake business on the island. The cakes are beautiful and made to order with a ton of options for flavors. Let’s support local small business! – JG